Charles Sanders Peirce (1839-1914)
A Brief Outline of His Philosophy
with some relations to linguistics
by Eugene Halton (c) 1992
"The agility of the tongue is shown in its insisting that the world depends upon it." --Peirce
Charles Sanders Peirce (1839-1914) is generally regarded as the founder of philosophical pragmatism, and, with Saussure, of modern semeiotic, and also as one of the founders of mathematical or symbolic logic. He was also deeply absorbed by linguistic researches throughout his life, learning languages in remote areas while travelling on geodetic surveys. His first published paper was on Shakespearean pronunciation.
A natural scientist by training and the son of the eminent mathematician Benjamin Peirce, he developed the philosophical basis of semeiotic in a series of articles in the late 1860s ("Questions Concerning Certain Capacities Claimed for Man," "Some Consequences of Four Incapacities"). There Peirce levelled a devastating critique of Cartesian philosophy and foundationalism, arguing that all cognition is irreducibly triadic, of the nature of a sign, fallible, and thoroughly immersed in a continuing process of interpretation. He considered his semeiotic (as he spelled it, in contrast with current usage of "semiotics" as an inclusive term for all the various studies of signs) as a general theory of logic, and saw language as but a portion of semeiosis.
Some of Peirce's letters to Lady Welby were included in the appendix to Ogden and Richards The Meaning of Meaning, and, with Charles Morris's largely unacknowledged appropriation of Peirce's ideas in his influential monograph Foundations of the Theory of Signs (1938), Peirce's ideas were problematically brought to the linguistics community and social sciences more generally.
Peirce's writings are pervaded by triadic divisions, which, given that he felt himself to be at heart a mathematician, he expressed most basically in numerical form as Firstness, Secondness, and Thirdness. While still in his twenties Peirce first began to formulate these divisions using personal pronouns: I (Firstness), IT (Secondness), and THOU (Thirdness). In Peirce's evolutionary cosmology, Thirdness, or triadic relation, or semeiosis, is considered to be a fact of the universe and not simply limited to the human mind, and therein lies the difference between Peirce and Kant, and between Peirce and much of modern linguistics and language theory.
By Peirce's semeiotic realism language does not simply refer to things outside of signs. Though largely of a conventional nature, language is a mode of conduct, and as such, produces conceivable consequences and is normatively bounded. In its abilities to body forth new possibilities for conduct, to determine and be determined by further experience, and to communicate valid generals bearing conceivable consequences, language is real, in Peirce's non-modern version of semeiotic realism. Both his realism and pragmatism are theoretically at odds with the positivism and behaviorism of Charles Morris, and to the nominalist conventionalism of Saussure and more recent poststructuralists. Though linguists and semioticians have been most fascinated by Peirce's elaborate triadic technical divisions of signs, such as icon, index, and symbol and type, token and (usually ignored) tone, the larger philosophical outlook and anthropology underlying those divisions have yet to be incorporated into linguistic studies.<>Major editions of Peirce's works include: The Essential Peirce: Selected Philosophical Writings, 2 Volumes; The Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce (1931-35, 1958) also available as CD-ROM (2002): Intelex; The New Elements of Mathematics by Charles S. Peirce (1973-76); Charles Sanders Peirce: Contributions to the Nation (4 Vols.: 1975, 1978, 1979, 1979); Semiotic and Significs: The Correspondence Between Charles S. Peirce and Victoria Lady Welby (1977). A projected 20 volume collection of Peirce's writings is currently underway, Writings of Charles S. Peirce: A Chronological Edition. Soon also available as CD-ROM, Intelex.
In addition, all of Peirce's published writings from his lifetime can be found on microfiche in Charles Sanders Peirce: Complete Published Works, Including Secondary Materials. Microfiche Edition (1977). His unpublished writings are collected on microfilm in The Charles S. Peirce Papers, Microfilm Edition, Thirty Reels with Two Supplementary Reels Later Added (1966).<> Peirce’s writings can also be found online at: Arisbe, Commens, Peter Batke, Peirce.org, and other locations. Also see relevant chapters in my books, Meaning and Modernity (University of Chicago Press, 1986), and Bereft of Reason (University of Chicago Press, 1995).>
Click to return to Eugene Halton's homepage .