| Fighting Irish Individual Awards: |
2010-2011 |
| National Tournament |
| Kevin Padden, First Team All-American |
| Robert Bauer, First Team All-American |
| Midwest 10 Conference Play & Tournament |
| Robert Bauer, First Team All-Midwest 10 |
| Notre Dame Invitational - All Tournament Team |
| Robert Bauer |
| Jim Waclawik |
| Jason Healy |
| Pat Laskowski |
| Steven Walsh |
| Peter Balestracci |
| Kevin Padden |
| Honorable Mention: Scott Canna |
| |
2009-2010 |
| Midwest 10 Conference Play & Tournament |
| Rob Bauer, First Team All-Midwest 10 |
| Mike Nejedly, First Team All-Midwest 10 |
| |
2006-2007 |
| Midwest 10 Conference Play & Tournament |
| John Tibble, Defensive Player of the Year, Midwest 10 |
| Dan Zibton, First Team All Midwest 10 |
| Nolan Kane, Honorable Mention All-Midwest 10 |
| |
| Hoosier-Illini Classic |
| Nolan Kane, West Team All Star Setter |
| |
| NIRSA Nationals |
| Dan Zibton, Men's Division I Honorable Mention |
|
|
| |
2005-2006 |
| Midwest 10 Conference Play & Tournament |
| Ryan Goes, Honorable Mention All-Midwest 10 |
| |
| NIRSA Nationals |
| John Tibble, Men's Division I Honorable Mention |
|