Interview excerpts from Andrew S.
Hughes, "When Stars Die," South
Bend Tribune, July 20, 1997. Followed by full article.
When Jimmy Stewart died on July 2nd,
it wasn't difficult to predict what would happen in the days afterward. Film
critics wrote tributes to the actor for his talent; editorial writers wrote
tributes to the man for his virtue and video stores experience to run on
Stewart's most popular films... In many cases, such as Stewart's, however, more
than just the person dies. The era he or she represents also ceases to exist.
"[The] Grape Road [mall] is Pottersville, and Jimmy
Stewart is dead," University of Notre Dame sociology professor Eugene
Halton says, referring to the uncaring, undemocratic capitalistic town of
Stewart's It's a Wonderful Life was set during the
fantasy sequence when Stewart sees what the world would have been like without
him.
Halton is the author of The Meaning of
Things and Bereft of Reason, a
book about contemporary social life and social thought.
"Perhaps part of the reason we feel sad about Jimmy Stewart's passing is
because we now live in Pottersville and something in us longs for the
small-town life that the character he portrayed stood for," Halton says.
"It probably touches on the public consciousness today that that
small-town feeling is gone for the most part."
What has replaced close-knit community associations has been a mega-mechanical
image of the world," Halton says.
"We have a whole modern world view which sees the universe as a vast
machine and that outlook is part of our culture, our economy, our policies, our
general outlook on things," he says.
The result is that life becomes mechanized and the
virtual reality of celebrity culture assuages the boredom of a bureaucratic,
mass existence.
Halton says normal socialization occurs through lessons gleaned from parents,
friends, teachers and other role models encountered face-to-face.
"In our modern mass-consumer society, those processes get infiltrated and
colonized by the mass media," he says. "Children get bombarded with
celebrity images and learn to identify with celebrity images. I think there's
something normal and identifying with heroes, but when it becomes pathological
is when the images one is constantly bombarded with stand for commercial,
ephemeral values."
Nothing, however, compares to television's influence - the
main source of those celebrity images - on our collective obsession with
celebrity.
Certainly there were celebrity deaths and funerals before
television - former Notre Dame football coach Knute Rockne's funeral was
broadcast on radio - but television's combination of visual images and
near-total saturation of the culture has made it the leading definer of
American culture since the 1950s.
For four days in November 1963, the nation watched
television, and the lines between hard news and entertainment news became
blurred forever.
"Kennedy is a real interesting transitional character
in the process of transforming politics into celebrity," Halton says.
"It's often claimed he's the first president to win the election through
television. So, with Kennedy, you have the first
president to enter office through television and who left office in a
shattering, tragic event portrayed through television. His death was probably
the first public outpouring of grief and a ritual of mourning conveyed directly
through television. I mean, I can tell you the rhythm of the drums on the march
to the cemetery."
The day the music
died
When John Lennon was murdered on
Dec. 8, 1980, many people said the former Beatle's death was the end of the
1960s. As many as 15,000 fans gathered in various cities across the globe to mourn
Lennon and the era he represented with candlelight vigils and sing-alongs.
In an odd way, celebrity deaths possess the ability to unite
people in a public form of grieving.
"That can give us the surrogate images of mourning and
grief and make it safe for us to experience them vicariously," Halton
says.
When Grateful Dead leader Jerry Garcia died on Aug. 9, 1995,
at California's Serenity Knowles drug re-habilitation center, vigils similar to
the ones held for Lennon - and Elvis Presley before him - occurred around the
country. The same thing had happened a year earlier when Nirvana leader Kurt Cobain
shot himself on April 8, 1994, at the age of 27... In the case of Garcia's
death, the vigils were even more endemic of the
culture that had sprung up around the 1960s rock band.
"I think it's interesting to ask why did
the Grateful Dead have such a large following of an almost
quasi-religious nature," Halton says. "I don't think it's just due to
their music, but to how the celebrity culture works in the Grateful Dead, which
is to give people surrogate feelings of community."
The vigils became virtual final conce1is for the band's
fans.
"That's the way they experienced Jerry Garcia, so they probably wanted to have a ritual of mourning closer to what the experience of Jerry Garcia was," Halton says. "Concerts are mass events with a very immediate sense of a mass of people, so maybe it's more important to have a grouping of people together."
... "Nothing sells like death," Orbit Music owner
Doug Zimmerman says. "That raises the profile of the artist ... People
don't miss something until it's no longer available to them. I think that,
coupled with the added publicity, people say, 'Maybe I should check it out and
see what the fuss is about.' "
Although Halton does not downplay the "vulturistic" nature of these sales increases, he does
see another, somewhat sentimental side to it.
"It's probably that phenomenon of seeing the person for
the last time, or a way of seeing a person for the last time, even though the
last time has already gone," he says.
... Just as romantic as Shakur's death for many teen-agers
was Kurt Cobain's suicide.
"His suicide was tragic, but what I find interesting is
that the teens who worship Cobain seem to deny the tragic aspects of his
death," Halton says. "His death seems to be a death denial for the
celebrity culture, a way of avoiding the bad feelings that caused his
suicide."
For Halton, such death denial is often a hallmark of how
society in general deals with a celebrity's death, thus making the event interesting.
''A lot of the culture of celebrity has kind of built into
ii the fountain of youth and death denial, so when a celebrity dies, it can be
taken as either a celebrity event or as an occasion for mourning, as in the
case of Jimmy Stewart, and down emotions, blue emotions, become something to be
experienced," Halton says. "Suddenly, there can be a general public
feeling of mourning for Jimmy Stewart, for the loss of that old, small-town
feeling, and personally, one can feel that one's grandfather is gone.
"Then, because of the dynamics of celebrity culture,
that has to be wiped clean by the next celebrity event..."