International Viewpoint on National ID Cards
| Topic Area |
Privacy |
| Target Audience |
Undergraduate and graduate level IS/CS/CS majors in general |
| Activity Type |
Research, presentations, and discussion |
| Time Required |
Usually two class period; may want a third class period |
| Attachments |
Worksheet One
Worksheet Two |
| Additional Material |
Privacy International. http://www.privacy.org |
| Background Needed to Complete the Assignment |
Basic knowledge of privacy issues and what a national id card is. |
| References |
None |
| Last Modified |
August 1999 |
Abstract:
Wih the advent of smart cards, cards containing a microprocessor and
memory, there are increasing proposals for establishment of a computerized
national identification card system. The card could be used when interacting
with government agencies and for any other transactions where a person's
identify must be verified. This assignment will investigate how different
countries have dealt with the national ID card scenario and the effects
on the individuals privacy.
Goals for the activity:
To make student aware that the issue of privacy and national id cards
is an international issue.
Knowledge/skills/attitudes to be developed (behavioral objectives)
Student will develop:
-
An international awarness of national id cards
-
Pro's and Con's of the national id cards from multiple countries
-
What countries have and do not have national id cards
Procedure:
-
First Class:
-
Discuss the basic premise of National ID Cards
-
Discuss the US standpoint on National ID Cards
-
Break students into groups of two or three.
-
Assign each team a country (pick countries that you know have issues with
National Id Cards, see www.privacy.org)
-
Research:
-
Between the two classes have the teams research their countries.
-
Complete worksheet one.
-
Create a 10 minute presentation based on the answers on worksheet one.
-
Second Class:
-
Each group presents their findings.
-
While groups are presenting students are required to fill out worksheet
two
-
At the end of class place completed worksheet two on overhead and allow
discussion (may want another class period)
Assessing Outcomes:
Several portions could be graded but one way to grade the student overall
perform is as follows;
| Activity |
Percentages
|
| Worksheet One |
25% |
| Presentation |
50%
|
| Worksheet Two |
25%
|
|
100%
|
Additional Remarks:
None
Author contact information:
Professor Jennifer A. Polack-Wahl
Mary Washington University
1301 College Avenue
Fredericksburg, VA 22401
E-mail: polack@mwc.edu