Of God and His Creatures
Some Discussion of the Question how there is in the
Divine Understanding a Multitude of Objects
THIS Multitude cannot be taken to mean that many objects of
understanding have a distinct being in God. For these objects of
understanding would be either the same with the divine essence, and at
that rate multitude would be posited in the essence of God, a doctrine
above rejected on many grounds (Chap. XXXI);
or they would be additions made to the divine essence, and at that rate
there would be in God some accident, which we have above shown to be an
impossibility (Chap. XXXIII). Nor again can
there be posited any separate existence of these intelligible forms,
which seems to have been the position of Plato, who, by way of avoiding
the above inconveniences, introduced the doctrine of Ideas. For the
forms of physical things cannot exist without matter, as neither can
they be understood without matter. And even supposing them so to
exist, even this would not suffice to explain God understanding a
multitude of objects. For, assuming the aforesaid forms to exist
outside the essence of God, and that God could not understand the
multitude of things without them, such understanding being requisite to
the perfection of His intellect, it would follow that God's perfection
in understanding depended on another being than Himself, and
consequently His perfection in being, seeing that His being is His
understanding: the contrary of all which has been shown (Chap. XL). Moreover, assuming what shall be proved
hereafter (Bk II, Chap. XV), that whatever is beyond the essence of God
is caused by God, the above forms, if they are outside of God, must
necessarily be caused by Him. But He is cause of things by His
understanding, as shall be shown (Bk II, Chap. XXIII, XXIV). Therefore
God's understanding of these intelligible forms is a natural
prerequisite for the existence of such forms. God's understanding then
of the multitude of creatures is not to be explained by the existence
of many intelligible abstract forms outside of God.
1.50 : That God has a Particular Knowledge of all things
1.52 : Reasons to show how the Multitude of Intelligible Ideal Forms has no Existence except in the Divine Understanding